47 This or That Questions Game About The Summer I Turned Pretty: Conrad vs. Jeremiah and More

Coke or Pepsi? Conrad or Jeremiah? Life is full of interesting ‘this or that’ questions (especially about The Summer I Turned Pretty). The format makes for great games to play in the car, on roadtrips, during sleepovers, or whenever you’re hanging out with friends.

As everyone waits to find out who Belly ends up with in The Summer I Turned Pretty season 3, it’s the perfect time for a TSITP-themed version of the classic would-you-rather style game. This one asks the tough questions: which new season 3 character is your ultimate favorite? Which parent is parenting the best? Would you rather spend time in Cousins or at Finch College?

If you're enjoying the game of deciding who should win Belly's heart, you're not alone. “I think we see with a lot of these love-triangle stories, people want the leading girl to end up with someone,” Lola Tung, who plays Belly in the show, told Teen Vogue about the debate between Conrad and Jeremiah. “When people have an attachment to the characters, they want to see it come together at the end."

That said, Tung clarified, it's good to have some limits as a fan. It's all in fun, after all. "I’m so grateful that they care so much, but people get a little scary about it. Please don't threaten to kill someone if something doesn't go your way — I promise you, it's not that serious. Jenny [Han] is so smart and she cares so much about the story and making it the best story that it can be. It will be okay.”

Below, try out these 47 this or that questions about The Summer I Turned Pretty, including season 3 characters, plot details, and more.

1. Conrad Fisher or Jeremiah Fisher?
2. Belly Conklin or Steven Conklin?
3. Conrad or Cam Cameron?
4. Taylor Jewel or Belly?
5. Taylor or Shayla?
6. Skye or Aunt Julia?
7. Cam Cameron or Skye?
8. Nicole or Shayla?
9. Nicole or Belly?
10. Shayla or Skye?
11. Susannah Fisher or Laurel Park?
12. Adam Fisher or John Conklin?
13. Cleveland Castillo or John Conklin?
14. Adam or Aunt Julia?

1. Cousins Beach or Finch College?
2. Country club or boardwalk carnival?
3. Beach volleyball or rock climbing wall?
4. Taylor Swift or Benson Boone?
5. Taylor Swift or Olivia Rodrigo?
6. “You’re Losing Me” or “exile”?
7. “Forever and Always” or “Summer Love”
8. Conrad’s gifts to Belly: Junior Mint polar bear or infinity necklace?
9. Conrad’s infinity necklace or Jeremiah’s guilt beach bracelet?
10. Infinity necklace or Catbird engagement ring?
11. Kiss in the sand or kiss in the pool?
12. Coordinated house party dance or rap song written about you?
13. Steven’s finance job or Conrad’s budding medical career?
14. Summer job: Internship in finance or PR?
15. Summer job: Lifeguard or restaurant server?

1. Belly’s white debutante dress, or Belly’s lilac prom dress?
2. Conrad in rugby shirts or Jeremiah in rugby shirts?
3. Belly in high school or Belly in college?
4. Steven in a work suit or Steven in crocs?
5. Belly in Christmas pajamas or Belly in casual Finch college clothes?
6. Belly’s wedding dress or Belly’s deb ball dress?
7. Susannah’s flowery dresses or Laurel’s minimalist sets?

1. Taylor or Anika?
2. Lucinda Jewel or Laurel?
3. Lucinda or Taylor?
4. Lucinda or Adam?
5. Lacie Barone or Redbird?
6. Lacie or Denise?
7. Denise or Taylor?
8. Lacie or Agnes?
9. Agnes or Belly?
10. Agnes or Anika?
11. Agnes or Taylor?

Agnes Is Conrad's 'Unpaid Therapist' in TSITP Season 3, Says Zoé de Grand'Maison

"He has an actual therapist, but…"